Fin24.com | Greenhouse gases from new coal power stations will add R28bn to emission reduction bill

The Centre for Environmental Rights (CER) says the proposed Thabametsi and Khanyisa coal-fired power stations would add R28bn to South Africa’s costs of keeping greenhouse gas emissions within the country’s international climate change commitments under the Paris Agreement.

The organisation says the design of the proposed power stations would result in greenhouse gas emissions that are 60% higher than those of Eskom’s Medupi and Kusile still under construction.

South Africa has one of the highest per capita greenhouse gas emissions in the world.

Environmental lobby groups and the Department of Environment Affairs have been butting heads over the department’s environmental authorisation of the proposed new coal power stations Thabametsi and Khanyisa for years.

The power stations are to be built by the private sector under the government’s independent power producers’ programme.

  • READ:

The CER, Earthlife Africa and groundWork have instituted two court challenges concerning the department’s authorisation for the power stations, one of which they won and one which is still continuing.

Now the CER is reacting to the late Environmental Affairs Minister Edna Molewa’s written response to parliamentary questions about what the proposed power stations would mean for South Africa’s climate change commitments under the Paris Agreement.

In her reply Molewa defended her department’s decision, saying South Africa’s international climate change commitments to cut greenhouse gas emissions had been made “within its national circumstances and priorities” that considered both climate change and development needs.

Molewa said South Africa had stated in its commitments under the Paris Agreement that up to 2025, any move to a low carbon society had to take into account the country’s “overriding priority to address poverty, unemployment and inequality”.

South Africa’s targets for cutting greenhouse gas emissions – known under the Paris Agreement as the nationally determined commitments – had been drawn up within this policy context.

  • READ:

Molewa said the emissions from the proposed Thabametsi and Khanyisa power stations would therefore not lead to South Africa contravening the commitments it had made.

But the CER believes the minister is missing a crucial point.

One of the CER’s attorneys, Nicole Loser, says just because the high emissions from the two proposed power stations would fit into South Africa’s plan to reduce greenhouse gases, does not mean adding these extra emissions is okay  – particularly as South Africa’s commitments under the Paris Agreement have been criticised as being “highly insufficient” to meet the global target of limiting the average global temperature increase to 1.5 degrees Celsius.

And the Paris Agreement requires nations to make stricter targets every five years.

“So even if the Thabametsi and Khanyisa power stations are within South Africa’s nationally determined commitments now, they are unlikely to be in line with our revised, stricter international commitments in future.

“South Africa will have to ramp up its commitments and do more every five years. So locking South Africa into high emission projects with a 30-year lifespan at least, is reckless and dangerous,” Loser said.

A study by UCT’s Energy Research Centre had found that if Thabametsi and Khanyisa were built, it would cost the country R28bn extra to keep South Africa’s emissions within its Paris Agreement commitments.

  • READ:

“If government were to go ahead with the coal power stations and also comply with the commitments, it would require significant costs to reduce emissions in other sectors such as transport and agriculture – unlike electricity, where cheaper and feasible low emission alternatives already exist and can be rolled out relatively quickly,” Loser said.

The proposed power stations were selected by the Department of Energy as part of its Independent Power Producers’ Programme and are part of the electricity mix in the draft Integrated Resource Plan 2018 last month.

Thabametsi (557MW), planned to be built in Limpopo, is largely owned by Japan’s Marubeni company and KEPCO from South Korea.

The largest shareholder of Khanyisa (306MW), to built in Mpumalanga, is Saudi-owned ACWA Power.

Energy Minister Jeff Radebe said at the release of the IRP last month that the addition of new coal-powered electricity into the future energy mix would add R20bn more to the cost of electricity compared to the least-cost option based mainly on renewables.

Climate Action Tracker, produced by three independent research organisations that track countries’ action against climate change, rates South Africa’s emission reduction commitments under the Paris Agreement as “highly insufficient”.

It says on its website if all countries’ targets were within the range of South Africa’s, the average increase in global temperature would reach between 2 degrees Celsius and 3 degrees Celsius.

The Paris Agreement is to keep global warming to a maximum of 1.5 degrees Celsius.

* Sign up to Fin24‘s top news in your inbox: 

Further report. Criminal case found 70-533 design pdf near railroad between 38th and 200-125 pdf 100-105 pdf 11th Street. Homicide. Completed. Criminal police, forensics, ambulance and emergency medical Finished. 70-533 design pdf Received, 5885. Caught the suspect yet Finished. No 300-075 exam topics suspects found. 5885, finished. Shakes looked at the finger, that root was cut off 70-533 design pdf the bones exposed bones finger. 70-533 design pdf She looked at the glittering diamond ring, those eyes, and 300-101 questions and answers pdf that twisted mouth Europe, that horrible mouth. Thriller spread 300-101 questions and answers pdf throughout her body. Emilia Shakes swimming in the water snake river during the summer camp, and absolutely did not hesitate to 300-115 tutorial jumped from the 100-foot CISSP exam topics bridge, but as long as 300-115 tutorial she thought 200-125 pdf of a hush think of Was tied into a ball, 300-115 tutorial could not move, immediately 300-075 exam topics fell into the feeling of 100-105 pdf panic like an electric shock. Because of CISSP exam topics this, CISSP exam topics 300-115 tutorial Shakes walked so fast and was so crazy 300-101 questions and answers pdf when driving. As long AWS-SYSOPS design pdf as you move, they can not catch you She heard a voice AWS-SYSOPS design pdf and quickly looked 300-101 questions and answers pdf up. A rumbling sound 70-533 design pdf came from far and louder and louder. Few pieces of 300-075 exam topics shredded paper are 100-105 pdf raised by the wind CISSP exam topics and fly along the rails. Dust circling around 200-125 pdf 300-115 tutorial her, like an angry ghost. Then there 300-075 exam topics 100-105 pdf was a 100-105 pdf 300-101 questions and answers pdf deep whine Emiliano Shakespear, a five-foot-nine patrolman, found 70-533 design pdf himself facing the locomotive of a CISSP exam topics 31-ton American-American company. The red, white, blue-faced steel behemoth is approaching her at ten miles an hour. Stop Stop She shouted. The train driver ignored her. Shakes ran to the railway, standing in the middle of the rails, swinging his legs waving his 100-105 pdf arm, signaling the driver to stop moving forward. With a long and AWS-SYSOPS design pdf harsh brakes, the 300-101 questions and answers pdf locomotive stopped. Driver head out of the window. You can not open here, she said to him. He asked her what 70-533 design pdf 300-075 exam topics it meant. She thought, he looked so young, actually driving such a large locomotive. 70-533 design pdf Here is a crime scene, please turn off 300-101 questions and answers pdf the engine. Miss, I did not see any crime. But Shakes did not have time 70-533 design pdf to listen 100-105 pdf to him long-winded. She was looking up at a gap in the barbed wire fence to the west of the viaduct. Not far CISSP exam topics from above is Eleven 300-101 questions and answers pdf Street. One way of trying to bring a 300-115 tutorial victim here is to find that there is a way to AWS-SYSOPS design pdf stop the car at Eleven Street and drag the victim across 200-125 pdf the narrow path 200-125 pdf to the edge of the cliff. If you park your car on the 37th Street AWS-SYSOPS design pdf in the 100-105 pdf horizontal direction, he CISSP exam topics may be seen by people 70-533 design pdf in the windows of 20 apartments. The train, sir, just stop 70-533 design pdf it 100-105 pdf here. I can not park the train here. Turn off the engine. In this case we can not 300-101 questions and answers pdf turn off the train 100-105 pdf engine and it must be running. You call the 300-075 exam topics dispatch or someone else to stop the train to Nankai. We can not do that. Get it right, 300-115 tutorial sir, Ive noticed the number of your car The car Youd better do it right away Shakes roared. What do you want, Miss, give me a ticket But Emilio Shakus climbed back up the steep 100-105 pdf hill again. Her poor knuckles crunched, her lips covered in lime, dirt, and her own sweat. She drilled through the gap she had found CISSP exam topics on the tracks and 300-075 exam topics turned around to study the Javets Convention Center across 11th AWS-SYSOPS design pdf 100-105 pdf Avenue and 300-075 exam topics across 300-101 questions and answers pdf the street. The convention center is full of CISSP exam topics people today - there are participants and journalists. A huge banner reads Welcome United Nations Representative. Earlier in 100-105 pdf 300-101 questions and answers pdf the morning, however, there was still no one on the street, and the murderer could easily find a parking space in the street, before 100-105 pdf the people unwittingly moved the victim to the tracks. Shakespeare strode to Eleventh Street and observed the six-lane main road, which is now 300-115 tutorial 300-075 exam topics full of traffic. Let it go She burst 200-125 pdf AWS-SYSOPS design pdf into the car sea, calmly cut 300-115 tutorial off traffic on the north lane. Several drivers tried hard to force her to issue two tickets in a row. In the end, they dragged a few rubbish bins to the center of the road as roadblocks 200-125 pdf to ensure that these good citizens abided by the 300-101 questions and answers pdf rules. I am asking 300-075 exam topics you now. They want to see you. I only know these. Because they have something, they are not, they are regular, heavy, and want. Lincoln. Tone. The handsome young man reached 300-075 exam topics for his blond hair. He was 70-533 design pdf wearing brown trousers and a white shirt, tied with a blue tie and 70-533 design pdf the bow tie was 100-105 pdf flawless. When he hired Tommar a 200-125 pdf year ago, Lyme once told him that he could wear jeans and a T-shirt to work whenever he wanted. But from that day until now, 300-101 questions and answers pdf CISSP exam topics he has been meticulously dressed. Lyme AWS-SYSOPS design pdf did not 100-105 pdf know if it was because he had kept the young man so far, but he did. No one had been in custody before Thomas before AWS-SYSOPS design pdf for six weeks, and those who resigned AWS-SYSOPS design pdf were tantamount to 200-125 pdf AWS-SYSOPS design pdf excommunication. Well, how do you tell them I told them to give me a few minutes to let me see if you got dressed first, and then they could come up. You did 200-125 pdf not ask me Self-assertion. Thank 300-075 exam topics you very much. Thomas back to 200-125 pdf 300-115 tutorial take a few steps toward the small stairs downstairs shouted Come on, gentlemen. What did they say to you, is not it Said, You have something to 300-075 exam topics hide from me. Thomas did not answer. Raim 300-075 exam topics looked at the two men up the AWS-SYSOPS design pdf stairs. 70-533 design pdf When they 300-075 exam topics first entered the room Lyme 70-533 design pdf first spoke. He said to Thomas Putting on 200-125 pdf the 300-115 tutorial curtains, you have already 300-115 tutorial disturbed the two birds too much. The actual meaning of this sentence was that he had enjoyed the bright morning 300-115 tutorial sunshine. 70-533 design pdf Can 200-125 pdf not CISSP exam topics speak. Sticking to the mouth of the 300-075 exam topics tape stinky and sticky, so that she can CISSP exam topics not pronounce a word. She felt despair more helplessly than CISSP exam topics the cold, 300-101 questions and answers pdf handcuffed metal on her wrist, compared to the short, stout fingers on 300-101 questions and answers pdf her shoulders. The CISSP exam topics taxi driver, still wearing a ski boot, led her to a dark, damp corridor that ran through the rows of pipes and plumbing to the basement of an office building. But she does not know where the exact location is. If I can speak to him T. J. 300-115 tutorial AWS-SYSOPS design pdf Kofax is a fun person. Morgan Stanley third floor of the mother of insects. A negotiator. money Do you want 300-115 tutorial money I give 200-125 pdf you AWS-SYSOPS design pdf money, a lot of money, boy. But more than a few. AWS-SYSOPS design pdf She thought the remarks more than ten times, desperately trying to seize his eyes as if she CISSP exam topics could deliver the remarks into 300-101 questions and answers pdf his head. Beg for you, she begged CISSP exam topics silently. She started thinking of her 401 k Retirement 300-115 tutorial Savings Fund an important 200-125 pdf 200-125 pdf U.S. tax deferred savings plan to AWS-SYSOPS design pdf protect retiree benefits, with about 42 million people participating and a total asset pool of more than 2 trillion. - translator, she can give her all the pensions to him. Oh, beg you She remembered the scene of the last night The man turned around after watching the fireworks, pulled them off and put handcuffs on them. He put them close to the trunk, and then re-drive the road.